Rey Mysterio's career features intense storylines marked by psychological warfare and personal vendettas. Among the darkest are these five moments, including the infamous murder plot.
1. Eddie Guerrero Murder Plot (2005)
The Eddie Guerrero feud escalated into a murder plot storyline after Eddie falsely claimed paternity of Rey's nephew Dominic. In a climactic segment, Guerrero orchestrated Rey's "murder" in a staged car explosion, heightening the storyline's psychological torment and violence. The plot explored themes of betrayal and loss, culminating in a bitter rivalry that pushed Rey to emotional lows.
2. Dominic Custody Ladder Match
Following the murder plot, Rey engaged in a custody battle over Dominic against his own son (in storyline terms). The feud led to a high-stakes ladder match where Rey defended his role as guardian. Symbolizing the erosion of family bonds, the match featured brutal physicality and psychological manipulation, casting Rey as a victim of relentless personal attacks.
3. CM Punk's Mask Removal Threats
In 2009, CM Punk targeted Rey's iconic mask— a symbol of his cultural identity— during the Straight Edge Society storyline. Punk vowed to forcibly unmask Rey, launching psychological assaults through promos and attacks. This dark saga exploited Rey's heritage, creating intense matches focused on humiliation and the threat to his legacy.
4. Big Show Feud and Humiliation Tactics
During a 2006 rivalry, The Big Show exploited Rey's smaller stature with taunts about his family and masculinity. Segments included Show destroying Rey's car and mocking his vulnerabilities, emphasizing physical dominance. The humiliation intensified in matches like a "No Holds Barred" encounter, portraying Rey as constantly undermined in his personal life.
5. Kane's Family Terror Campaign
In 2010, Kane unleashed a series of attacks on Rey and his family, framing it as a deranged quest for dominance. The storyline involved stalking segments and invasions of Rey's home, escalating to violent encounters where Kane threatened to "end" Rey's career. This era focused on real-world fears, heightening the darkness through implied violence and emotional torment.
